Lettuce (Lactuca sativa L.) is one of the most popular salad crops and occupies the largest production area among salad crops in the world. However, production of lettuce can be limited due to lack of improved production techniques. Farmers in northwestern Ethiopia didn’t apply mulching for lettuce. A field study was conducted at Teda in 2018 to evaluate the effect of different mulching materials on yield and yield component of lettuce (Lactuca sativa L.) under irrigation. Five mulching materials used as a treatment viz: white plastic, black plastic, teff straw, chickpea straw and control (without mulch). The treatments were laid out in Randomized Complete Block Design (RCBD) with four replications. Application of mulching increased leaf width, leaf number, plant height, biological yield, root volume, dry matter and plant height. The highest and lowest yield was recorded for black plastic mulch and no mulch, respectively. The study revealed that the black plastic is the best mulching material among the organic and inorganic once for the production of lettuce in the study area.
Lettuce (Lactuca sativa L.) an annual leafy herb belongs to the family of Astaraceae is one of the most popular salad crops and occupies the largest production area among salad crops in the world. Lettuce is ranked 26th among vegetables and fruits in terms of nutritive value and 4th in terms of consumption. It is the most popular salad crop in the world and because of used crude, its vitamins inter to human body without change .The nutrient content is highest in the darker green, outer leaves  . It is popular for its delicate, crispy texture and slightly bitter taste with milky juice as fresh condition. It is the most popular amongst the salad vegetable crops  . Lettuce is originated from Southern Europe and Western Asia and its early forms were used in Egypt around 4500 BC. The Romans grew types of lettuce resembling the present romaine cultivars as early as the beginning of the Christian era. The crop was also used in China by the 7th century A.D.  . It mainly grows in temperate region and in some cases in the tropic and subtropic region of the world. Lettuce largely produced in greenhouse in temperate region  .
Lettuce is rich in vitamin A and minerals like calcium and iron. It also contains protein, carbohydrate and vitamin C and in 100 g of edible portion of lettuce contains 93.4 g moisture, 2.1 g protein, 0.3 g fat, 1.2 g minerals, 0.5 g fiber, 2.5 g carbohydrates, 310 mg calcium, 80 mg phosphorus, 2.6 mg iron, 1650 I.U. vitamin A, 0.09 mg thiamine, 0.13 mg riboflavin and about 10.0 mg vitamin C  .
Lettuce is one of the major vegetable crops produced in Ethiopia. Ethiopia is one of a few market developing countries that have been producing lettuce for local consumption  . It is extensively grown in most parts of Ethiopia on diverse ecology. Plastic mulches are commonly used in vegetable as well as fruit crops production. In vegetable production, numerous advantages had been reported. One of the advantages is it greatly reduces water evaporation from the soil so it minimizes dryness of the soil and thus reduces the frequency of watering. Another and one of the common reasons for its use is to hold the temperature of the soil significantly above what it would otherwise be. Plastic mulches directly impact the microclimate around the plant by modifying the radiation budget thus decreasing the soil water loss. Mulch color determines its energy-radiating behavior and its influence on the microclimate around a vegetable plant.
Mulching materials have effect on the seedling emergence and growth performance of lettuce by affecting soil temperature, soil structure, soil moisture and weed emergence, these all factors affects the yield and yield components of lettuce including germination percentage  .
Knowing the effect of different mulching material is very important because most of the time producers of lettuce do not consider about effect of mulch. As a result this study was conducted to investigate the effects of different mulching materials on the yield and yield component of lettuce at Teda, Central Gondar, Ethiopia.
Materials and Methods
Description of the Study Area
Field experiment was conducted in University of Gondar, College of Agriculture and Rural Transformation in Horticulture demonstration site at Teda during 2018 under irrigation from February to May, 2018. The experimental site is located in the geographical location of between longitude 370-480 E to W and latitudes 120-240 N to S. The experimental site lies at an altitude of about 2380 m.a.s.l with the mean annual rainfall of 992.5 mm. The area experiences medium unimodal rainfall distribution pattern which extends from June to Mid-September. The soil type is vertisol and characterized with 5.5 pH. The average annual maximum and minimum temperature are 28.5°C and 13.5°C, respectively (Melaka et al., 2008).
Experimental Material and Experimental
In this study a lettuce variety “great lake” was used as a test crop. Treatments were teff straw, chickpea straw, white plastic sheet, black plastic sheet and no mulch were laid in Randomized Complete Block Design (RCBD) with four replications. The single plot size was 1.5m*1.8m (2.7m2) accommodating four rows. In the study, spacing of 25 cm and 45cm was used between plants and rows, respectively. The path between blocks and plots were 0.6m and 0.5m, respectively. Each treatment was randomly assigned to each plot.
Growth and yield parameters were collected during the field experiment by sampling five randomly selected plants from central rows of each experimental unit. Data on plant height, leaf number, leaf length, leaf width, root volume, dry matter content and marketable yield was recorded.
The data collected were subjected to analysis of variance (ANOVA) according to the procedures stated by Gomez and Gomez (1984) using Statistical Analysis System (SAS) version 9 software package and least significant difference (LSD) was used to separate means at 0.05 probability levels of significance.
Results and Discussion
The analysis of variance showed that there was significant difference (P<0.01) among treatments on the effect of leaf length (Table 1). Thus the highest leaf length (14.36cm) was obtained from plot covered by black plastic whereas the lowest (8.91cm) was obtained from control treatment. This might be due the effect of black plastic on soil moisture conservation which ultimately increase nutrient uptake of plant  . This result has conformity with the finding of  who reported that growing of lettuce under mulching resulted in the highest leaf length than control treatment.
The leaf width of lettuce was significantly (P < 0.01) influenced by tested treatments. Application of black plastic resulted in the highest leaf width (17.29cm) whereas the lowest was obtained from control treatment (11.23cm) (Table 1). This might be due to the positive effect of plastic mulches on enhancing microbial activity in the soil (Brault et al., 2002). Similar results were obtained by Mutetwa and Mtaita (2014) who indicated that yield of vegetables can be increased through application of mulches. mulches might have provided a suitable condition for producing higher number of leaves in the plants  . The current result is in line with the finding of Tosic et al., (2014) who conclude that mulching had positive effect on leaf number of lettuce as compared to control treatment (no mulching).
Plant height was significantly (P<0.01) influenced by the effect of treatments. Thus the highest plant height (16.43cm) was recorded from black mulch while the shortest (11.24cm) was obtained from control treatment (Table 1). The result had conformity with the findings of Yaghi et al. (2013) on cucumber and Ashrafuzzaman et al. (2011) on lettuce who reported that increased vegetative growth and plant height under the application of black plastic mulch, respectively. The faster growing stem of the lettuce grown on black mulch may be due to the effect of higher temperature around the growing point (Brault et al., 2002).
The analysis of variance revealed that there was significant difference (P<0.05) among the effects of treatments on leaf number. The highest leaf number (17.62) was obtained from the black mulch whereas the lowest (14.97) was obtained from control treatment (Table 1). The microclimate condition improved by the plastic Table1: Effect of mulch on leaf length, leaf width, leaf number, plant height
|Mulching material||Leaf length (cm)||Leaf width (cm)||Leaf number/plant||Plant height (cm)|
|Black plastic||14.36 a||17.295a||17.62a||16.43a|
|Control ( No mulch )||8.91c||11.235c||14.97c||11.24c|
Effect of mulch on leaf length, leaf width, leaf number, plant height
Means with in column sharing common letters are not significant different at p<0.05.
The root volume of lettuce was significantly influenced by mulch type. Thus the highest (4.76 cm3) was obtained from black plastic (2.59 cm3) while the lowest was obtained from control treatment (Table 2). Mulches had significant positive effects on root elongation. This might be due to the conservation of enough soil moisture, suitable soil temperature as well as suitable microclimate condition. This result coincides with that of Ashrafuzzaman et al. (2011) who reported that black polythene mulch stimulates root growth.
The analysis of variance showed that there was significant (P < 0.01) difference among treatments. The maximum (4.59%) dry matter was obtained from black plastic whereas the minimum (1.65%) was obtained from control treatment (Table 2). This result is in line to the result of Maboko et al. (2017) who reported that plastic mulches had a good comparative effect on leaf dry mass of Swiss chard as compared to other type of organic mulches and bare-soil. The positive effect was probably due to the reduction of nutrients lost due to leaching  , reaction of soil heat  , and moisture conservation by mulching  . Similarly organic mulches had nutrient recycling system for green waste in cities  .
The analysis of variance indicated that there was significant difference among treatments on the effect of marketable yield. Thus the highest Table 2: Effect of mulch on root volume, dry matter content and marketable yield of lettuce Treatments (Mulching Root volume Dry matter content Marketable yield
Means with in column sharing common letters are not significant different at p<0.05. marketable yield (33.34 ton/ha) was obtained from black mulch while the lowest (18.53 ton/ha) was obtained from control treatment (Table 2). This might be because of black polyethylene mulch controlled all types of weeds in addition to soil moisture conservation  . Similarly, Yaghi et al. (2013) reported that plastic mulch raised soil temperature of the planting field which promote faster crop development and earlier yield.
|Treatments ( Mulching materials )||Root volume (cm 3 )||Dry matter content (%)||Marketable yield (ton/ha)|
|Control ( No mulch )||2.59b||1.65d||18.53b|
Effect of mulch on root volume, dry matter content and marketable yield of lettuce
Conclusion and Recommendation
The use of black plastic mulch resulted in the highest leaf length, leaf width, plant height, leaf number, root volume, dry matter content and marketable yield of lettuce whereas the lowest was obtained from control treatment (no mulching).
Generally application of black plastic mulch gave highest yield of lettuce than other mulches. This indicated that black plastic mulch has great impact on yield of lettuce and this result may be due to increment of soil temperature and soil moisture which ultimately resulted in high yield of lettuce crop. Therefore, lettuce growers should be advised to utilize black plastic mulch to maximize lettuce productivity.
- Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) .. CrossRef Google Scholar
- Geographical distribution, diversity and gap analysis of East African sorghum collection conserved at the ICRISAT genebank Upadhyaya HariD, Narsimha ReddyK, Vetriventhan M, Murali KrishnaG, Irshad AhmedM, Manyasa E, Thimma ReddyM, Singh ShaileshKumar, and Australian Journal of Crop Science.2017-apr;:424-437. CrossRef Google Scholar
- THE COMPARISON BETWEEN THE THERMAL PERFORMANCE OF A CONTEMPORARY HOUSE AND TRADITIONAL HOUSE IN THE DENSE DHAKA CITY IN BANGLADESH Rumana RASHID, Ahmed MohdHamdanBin. DIMENSI (Jurnal Teknik Arsitektur).2013-oct. CrossRef Google Scholar
- ON THE ORIGIN OF CULTIVATED LETTUCE LINDQVIST K. Hereditas.2010-jul;:319-350. CrossRef Google Scholar
- Medical Research Council (Special Report Series 279) Plant Proteins in Child Feeding Postgraduate Medical Journal.1954-may;:262-262. CrossRef Google Scholar
- Correlation and Path Coefficient Analysis of Hot Pepper (Capsicum annuum L.) Genotypes for Yield and its Components in Ethiopia Shumbulo Abrham, Nigussie Mandefro, Alamerew Sentayehu. Advances in Crop Science and Technology.2017. CrossRef Google Scholar
- Introduction. Bosland PW, Votava EJ. Peppers: vegetable and spice capsicums.;:1-12. CrossRef Google Scholar
- EFFECTS OF CATTLE MANURE APPLICATION ON GROWTH AND MARKETABLE YIELD OF TRADITIONAL OKRA (CORCHORUS OLITORIUS L.) IN SWAZILAND Masarirambi MT, Nkomo M, Oseni TO, Wahome PK. Acta Horticulturae.2013-sep;:339-346. CrossRef Google Scholar
- Presentación Castillo ManuelÁngel. Estudios Demográficos y Urbanos.2015-sep. CrossRef Google Scholar
- Effect of Colored Plastic Mulches on Yield of Tomato and Weed Biomass Rajablariani HamidReza, Hassankhan Farzad, Rafezi Ramin. International Journal of Environmental Science and Development.2012;:590-593. CrossRef Google Scholar
- Effects of Plant Spacing and Mulching on Yield and Profitability of Lettuce ($\less$i$\greater$Lactuca sativa$\less$/i$\greater$ L.) Moniruzzaman M. Journal of Agriculture & Rural Development.2008-apr. CrossRef Google Scholar
- Evaluation of straw and polythene mulch for enhancing productivity of irrigated summer groundnut Ghosh PK, Dayal Devi, Bandyopadhyay KK, Mohanty M. Field Crops Research.2006-oct;:76-86. CrossRef Google Scholar
- Overview of organic agriculture. Kristiansen P, Merfield C. Organic agriculture: a global perspective.;:1-23. CrossRef Google Scholar
- Improving agri-food chain relationships in Europe: the role of public policy. Albisu LM, Henchion M, Leat P, Blandford D. Agri-food chain relationships.;:250-266. CrossRef Google Scholar
- Effect of plastic mulch on growth and yield of chilli (Capsicum annuum L.) Ashrafuzzaman M, Halim MAbdul, Ismail MohdRazi, Shahidullah SM, Hossain MAlamgir. Brazilian Archives of Biology and Technology.2011-apr;:321-330. CrossRef Google Scholar
- New Entomological Publications of the CAB International, UK Oriental Insects.1993-jan;:92-92. CrossRef Google Scholar
- Effect of Plastic Mulch Color on Leaf Anatomy of Lettuce (Lactuca sativa L.) Franquera Edmar, Mabesa Renato. Current Agriculture Research Journal.2015-dec;:105-108. CrossRef Google Scholar
- HTTP Reid Fiach. Network programming in .NET.2004;:87-130. CrossRef Google Scholar
- Effect of mulching on soil and plant water status, and the growth and yield of wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) in a semi-arid environment Chakraborty Debashis, Nagarajan Shantha, Aggarwal Pramila, Gupta VK, Tomar RK, Garg RN, Sahoo RN, Sarkar A, Chopra UK, Sarma KSSundara, Kalra N. Agricultural Water Management.2008-dec;:1323-1334. CrossRef Google Scholar
- Statistical Procedures for Agricultural Research with Emphasis on Rice. Freeman GH, Gomez KA, Gomez AA. Biometrics.1978-dec. CrossRef Google Scholar
- SWISS CHARD (Beta vulgaris var. cicla) Westcott\textquotesingles Plant Disease Handbook.;:1105-1106. CrossRef Google Scholar
- EFFECT OF DIFFERENT MULCH COLORS ON CUCUMBER PRODUCTION Mutetwa Moses, Mtaita Tuarira. Journal of Global Innovations in Agricultural and Social Sciences.2014-dec;:178-184. CrossRef Google Scholar
- The effect of plant mulching and covering on the lettuce yield and nitrate content (Lactuca sativa L.) Ivana Toić, \vZarko Ilin, Ivana Maksimović, Slobodanka Pavlović. African Journal of Agricultural Research.2014-jun;:1774-1777. CrossRef Google Scholar
- Cucumber (Cucumis sativus, L.) water use efficiency (WUE) under plastic mulch and drip irrigation Yaghi T, Arslan A, Naoum F. Agricultural Water Management.2013-oct;:149-157. CrossRef Google Scholar